- 2013
- 2012
- 2011
- 2010
- 2009
- 2008
- 2007
- 2006
- 2005
State Supreme Court Category Archives: State Supreme Court
Disbarred attorneys had multiple complaints, records show
CHARLESTON – Should they seek to again practice law in starting in 2013, John E. Lutz and Anthony Tatano will still have to answer to collectively a dozen clients why they failed in their legal duties. On Nov. 5, the … Read More
Justice remand gravel driveway case back to Cabell judge
CHARLESTON – Cabell Circuit Judge David Pancake peered at a deed and thought he saw an easement to a gravel driveway off a Huntington street. But, according to the state Supreme Court of Appeals, he just imagined it. The Justices … Read More
Court suspends one, disbars two attorneys
CHARLESTON – The licenses of three attorneys have either been suspended or annulled by recent order of the state Supreme Court. In a press release issued Nov. 19, the Office of Disciplinary Counsel, the investigative arm of the state Bar, … Read More
Justice Benjamin remembers Underwood
Underwood
CHARLESTON – West Virginia Supreme Court Justice Brent Benjamin issued the following statement Monday about the death of former Gov. Cecil Underwood:
Read More
Justices order new trial in Ohio Co. med mal case
CHARLESTON – Circuit Judge James Mazzone spoiled an Ohio County medical malpractice trial by approving a prospective juror who blamed malpractice verdicts for high insurance costs, according to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. The Justices on Nov. 6 … Read More
Living The Dream Award nominations sought
Starcher
CHARLESTON — State Supreme Court Justice Larry Starcher, as co-chairman of the Living the Dream Awards Committee, is soliciting nominations for the Martin Luther King Jr. West Virginia Holiday Commission awards.
Read More
Canterbury fires back at Morris’ claims
Canterbury
CHARLESTON – The state court Administrator has fired back about accusations made in the press by a recently fired Supreme Court employee.
Read More
Supreme Court denies Bayer tax breaks
Carper
CHARLESTON — A ruling issued Wednesday by the state Supreme Court confirmed a lower court’s findings that denied Bayer tax breaks it was seeking and saved Kanawha County from losing more than $1 million in tax revenue.
Read More
Justices block Pocahontas quarry
Starcher
CHARLESTON – To preserve tourism in Pocahontas County, the state Supreme Court has blocked operation of a 76-acre sandstone quarry. Read More
Fired Supreme Court worker says he is suspected of leaking Maynard photos
Maynard
CHARLESTON – A former state Supreme Court employee says the reason he was fired last week is because he is suspected of leaking photographs that might have cost Chief Justice Spike Maynard re-election and that he accused the court administrator of making racial comments in the office.
Read More
U.S. SC to rule on judicial recusal issue
Benjamin
WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court will decide if state Supreme Court Justice Brent Benjamin should have recused himself from the $50 million case of a heavy campaign supporter.
Read More
Justices reverse Cabell judge on med mal ruling
Cabell Huntington Hospital
CHARLESTON – Cabell Circuit Judge David Pancake misread a clock in West Virginia medical malpractice law by four years when he threw out a mother’s suit against Cabell Huntington Hospital, the Supreme Court of Appeals decided Nov. 6.
Read More
Justices block Cabell judge’s shot in Mayo case
Mayo
CHARLESTON – “Airball” sang out the state Supreme Court as the Justices reversed a Cabell Circuit Judge for attaching constitutional significance to O. J. Mayo’s participation in Huntington High School basketball games. Read More
Supreme Court weighs in on muddy, wirey issue
CHARLESTON – The state Supreme Court has overturned a decision that held three companies not liable for the injuries of a 13-year-old who was temporarily blinded by mud and rode into three of their wires. William Smoot II, by his … Read More
First probation officers to supervise sex offenders under new law
CHARLESTON — The first probation officers hired specifically to supervise sex offenders under provisions of the Child Protection Act of 2006 were sworn in Nov. 7 in the Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. Supreme Court … Read More



