Woman sues State Farm for son’s injuries, failing to pay out policy

By Kyla Asbury | Feb 26, 2016

WINFIELD – A woman is suing State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company after she claims her son was injured in a car accident and the company failed to pay out proper payments under the policies.


WINFIELD – A woman is suing State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company after she claims her son was injured in a car accident and the company failed to pay out proper payments under the policies.

On April 24, 2011, Alan Withrow, a minor, was a passenger involved in a single car accident in Interstate-95 near Waterboro, S.C., with his stepfather driving the 2009 Nissan Sentra, according to a complaint filed Feb. 4 in Putnam Circuit Court.

Natisha Martin, Withrow’s mother, claims she owned the vehicle and as a result of the accident, Withrow sustained a stage IVN renal injury that required his left kidney to be removed and he suffered bouts of pancreatitis.

Martin was insured by State Farm with coverage in the amount of 20/40 and her husband, Brian Martin, was insured by State Farm with coverage in the amount of 100/50, according to the suit.

Natisha Martin claims following notification of the accident and conducting an investigation of her claim, State Farm offered the sum of $25,000 and in addition, $5,000 of medical payments previously paid, as a compromise amount to settle all claims arising from the injuries to Withrow.

The offered settlement amount was pursuant to Natisha Martin’s policy and nothing was offered under Brian Martin’s policy, according to the suit.

Natisha Martin claims on June 6, 2013, she filed an amended petition in Putnam Circuit Court and on April 10, a hearing was held in which Circuit Judge Phillip Stowers ordered State Farm to confirm or deny any additional coverage for Withrow.

On May 11, State Farm provided the court with an analysis of coverage under the two policies and on Oct. 30, a hearing was held in which Stowers accepted the letter as being a denial of coverage of Withrow, according to the suit.

Natisha Martin claims State Farm failed to offer the highest level of coverage, being $100,000 under the contract language.

The defendant has also delayed settlement of Natisha Martin’s claim in failing to pay uninsured motorist coverage in accordance with West Virginia code and in accordance with the language of the insurance contract itself, according to the suit.

Natisha Withrow is seeking an order declaring that her son is entitled to an award of $100,000 as well as applicable medical payments from State Farm with its contract with its insured; declare that her son is entitled to an award of $20,000 in underinsured coverage per its contract; declare that her son is awarded medical payments of $5,000 and punitive damages.

She is being represented by Charles “Rusty” Webb of the Webb Law Centre PLLC.

Putnam Circuit Court case number: 16-C-41

Want to get notified whenever we write about any of these organizations ?

Sign-up Next time we write about any of these organizations, we'll email you a link to the story. You may edit your settings or unsubscribe at any time.

Organizations in this Story

Putnam Circuit Court State Farm Insurance Co. The Webb Law Firm, PLLC

More News

The Record Network